Recently in Three Strikes Law Category

June 16, 2010

Huntington Beach Postal Worker and Neighbor Hailed for Stopping Getaway by Burglar

As Anaheim burglary criminal defense attorneys, we were interested to see a recent article about a home-invasion burglar who was caught by a postal worker and a neighbor to the home. According to a June 11 story from the Orange County Register, Michael Dean Hester, 50, was arrested June 4 after the mailman for the area, Harold Dade, surprised him in the act of burglarizing the home of Denise Davis. Davis was not home at the time. Dade and neighbor Scott Stone chased down Hester as he left the scene. Hester is now charged with two counts of felony burglary, one count of felony receiving stolen property and one count of misdemeanor resisting arrest. He has pleaded not guilty. Because he has a felony criminal record, the district attorney's office said a conviction could mean a third strike.

Dade told the newspaper that he regularly delivers mail to Davis's home, so he noticed when an unfamiliar bicycle showed up in front. As he approached the front door, he also noticed that the glass in the door had been broken with a brick and realized something was amiss. Then he looked up and saw a man. Dade said he thought each of them scared the other, and ran back to his truck to call the police. On his way there, he noticed Stone in a car slowing down for a stop sign and asked him to call the police. While Stone was making that call, Hester left on the bicycle, so Stone followed him to a local McDonald's. He was able to identify the man for police when they arrived. Davis praised Dade and Stone for being neighborly and involved. She recovered some, but not all, of the stolen goods, and believes that another burglar may be at large with the remaining goods.

Our Whittier burglary criminal defense lawyers are pleased that these neighbors are looking out for one another. However, we'd like to focus on the possibility that Hester will be convicted of a third strike under the three-strikes law, which always means a sentence of 25 years to life in prison. Hester's first felony convictions were for grand theft of vehicles and receiving stolen property. That was in 1991, before the three-strikes law was passed in 1994, but those felony convictions can still count as priors. However, it's not clear that any of Hester's prior felony convictions are "strikes," because strikes are always serious or violent felonies. For example, grand theft auto in itself is not a strike, but it would be if Hester used a firearm or other dangerous or deadly weapon. His second felony convictions in 1995, two counts of receiving stolen property, would not count as strikes. However, the residential burglary charge Hester now faces is a strike, so he certainly needs experienced legal representation.

Continue reading "Huntington Beach Postal Worker and Neighbor Hailed for Stopping Getaway by Burglar" »

June 4, 2010

Huntington Beach Man Could Face 25 Years to Life for 'Keying' Neighbor's Car

Our Orange County vandalism criminal defense attorneys try to explain the importance of the three-strikes law to every client who is facing a charge for a "strike" crime. The three-strikes law substantially increases penalties for felonies after a previous conviction for certain felonies considered serious or violent. But it's very rare that we see this law invoked in the context of vandalism, as it was in a May 27 Huntington Beach Independent article. According to the article, John Patrick Rogers, 45, is accused of felony vandalism for "keying" and denting his neighbor's car. If he is convicted, and the judge does not disregard his previous convictions, Rogers could get 25 years to life in prison. The sentence for felony vandalism is ordinarily two to three years.

Rogers has two previous strikes, both for assault with a deadly weapon. The age and circumstances of those crimes was not reported. However, he's also known to the Huntington Beach Police Department as someone who has been arrested multiple times, often for less serious crimes. His record includes prior convictions for misdemeanor reckless driving, misdemeanor lewd conduct in public and disobeying a court order. He also has unspecified restraining orders against him. The article didn't describe the circumstances of the vandalism, but a Huntington Beach officer said Rogers was taken back into custody after initially being released on his own recognizance. The officer said the public was safer without Rogers in custody.

As Long Beach vandalism criminal defense lawyers, we suspect the real reason has to do with the time in prison Rogers is facing. Vandalism is not normally a serious enough crime to inspire defendants to flee. But thanks to the three strikes law, Rogers faces a minimum of 12.5 times the usual sentence, and a maximum of the rest of his life in prison. Under those circumstances, it's easy to see why law enforcement might think Rogers would flee. In fact, we believe this reflects the fundamental problem with the three-strikes law: it sometimes creates absurdly large sentences for relatively minor crimes. In cases like this one, whether the defendant is sentenced for a third "strike" is up to the judge's discretion -- which means a lot depends on what kind of judge the defendant gets. The help of an experienced attorney can also make a major difference in this kind of case.

Continue reading "Huntington Beach Man Could Face 25 Years to Life for 'Keying' Neighbor's Car " »